Kreeft: Learning From Islam
Catholic philospher and prolific author Peter Kreeft has a new book viewing Islam from a Christian prospective, Between Allah & Jesus: What Christians Can Learn from Muslims. Here's an excerpt from the Introduction:
Why the West Fears Islam
Many Christians today have a deep fear of Islam, as of no other religion. They have reasons: over three thousand of them after 9/11. Yet many Muslims, most Muslims in the West, and the vast majority in America, want to be our friends, not our enemies in our battle against our real common enemy, which is sin, Satan, selfishness and secularism. If those are not our real enemies, then Jesus and all the saints were fools. Why do Christians believe our irreligious media's picture of Muslims as hate-filled, violence-prone, ignorant, superstitious, irrational, fanatical terrorists? To the secular media, the only good Muslim is a bad Muslim, that is, a secularized one. The same media believes that the only good Christian is a bad Christian; that is, a secularized, de-supernaturalized, modernized, liberalized, compromised, rationalized one – especially one that worships the gods of the Sexual Revolution (the old one, I mean, not the new one expressed in John Paul II's Theology of the Body). To let this media define a religion for us is idiocy.
The secular media fear Islam for two reasons: (1) because they think it is the reason, or the rationalization, for nearly all the terrorism, murder and war in the world today, and (2) because it is deeply religious. The media believe these two things naturally go together. They are wrong.
What Christians should not learn from MuslimsWhile the subtitle of this book, and its main focus, is What Christians Can Learn from Muslims, there are many things that Christians should not learn from Muslims; for instance:
- Anger or jealousy at Western civilization
- Proneness or addiction to violence
- Politicizing religion (that always messed us up whenever we tried it!)
- Preventing apostasy by murdering apostates
- Treating women like slaves
- Prioritizing justice over mercy and forgiveness
- The continued chewing of centuries-old grudges
- Fear of freedom
- Fear of reasoning and dialogue
- Terrorism
- Theological voluntarism (the doctrine that God's will has no reason)
- Unitarianism (the theology that insists that the one God is only one Person, not three, and that
- Christ is only human, not divine)
With the exception of the last item, however, these are not essential parts of Islamic orthodoxy. If these ideas appear in the Qur'an at all, they are disapproved rather than approved. And they are not typical of all or even most serious Muslims in the world today, especially in the West, though they are typical of the ones we usually hear about in the news. For quiet piety does not make headlines; loud terrorist explosions do.
Please ask yourself whether you would like others to judge Christianity based on the picture of it now being presented in the modern Western media. Then please remember the Golden Rule, and apply this to the picture of Islam presented by the same source.
What Christians should Obviously Learn from MuslimsThere are also many things we Christians already know we can and should learn from Muslims, or be reminded of by Muslims. These are things which we already believe, though we do not practice them very well; for instance:
- Faithfulness in prayer, fasting and almsgiving
- The sacredness of the family and children and hospitality
- The absoluteness of moral laws and of the demand to be just and charitable
- The absoluteness of God and the need for absolute submission, surrender and obedience ("islam") to him
You will not find many Muslims anywhere who are indifferentists, moral pragmatists, hedonists, utilitarians, materialists, subjectivists, relativists or libertines.
The list of things Christians should not learn from Muslims is a list of things we already recognize as evils, and the list of things Christians should obviously learn from Muslims is a list of things we already recognize as goods. But there is a third thing, which is good, not evil, but which we do not clearly recognize as obviously good, and this is the thing we very much need to learn from Muslims. That's what this book is about.
It is not unique to Muslims. We could learn it from anyone, but Muslims seem to be the ones who are most clearly manifesting it today. So it is to the Muslims that we should turn to learn it – not primarily for the sake of being nice to Muslims or for religious harmony or ecumenism or even world peace, but for our own holiness and wholeness and humanity, our own supernatural and natural completing.
I find it hard to give a single name to this thing. I could call it something like the "spirit" of Islam, but that is far, far too slippery and subjective a term. Rather than telling you what it is, by defining it, like a philosopher, or by selling it, like a motivational speaker, I want to show you what it is, by exemplifying it, in a fictional character, like a novelist.
Here's the entire Introduction, and here's the book on Amazon.

Comments
Join the conversation. Post your comment below